10b5-1 Plans: Mortgaging a Defense Against Insider Trading - David Larcker, Brian Tayan

 
Abstract Text: In 2006, David Zucker, chief executive officer of Midway Games, came under fire for selling a significant amount of Midway stock just weeks before a precipitous decline in the company’s share price. One year later, Angelo Mozilo, chairman and chief executive officer of Countrywide Financial, also increased the pace of his stock sales in the months before troubles in the U.S. mortgage lending market led to a similar drop off in Countrywide’s share price. Both executives placed their trades through prearranged programs known as 10b5-1 plans. 10b5-1 plans, named after the Securities and Exchange Commission rule which led to their creation, provided a systematic method for corporate executives who were routinely in the possession of material nonpublic information to engage in the sale of company stock. When implemented appropriately, 10b5-1 plans provided a safe haven that shielded these individuals from liability under insider trading laws by demonstrating that certain safeguard conditions were in place at the time the trades were executed. However, the circumstances under which both executives carried out their programs led to an outcry from shareholders that the programs were being abused. Regulators and shareholders were left to decide whether the two men executed their 10b5-1 plans in good faith as required or whether their actions amounted to a sophisticated form of illegal insider trading.
Title: 10b5-1 Plans: Mortgaging a Defense Against Insider Trading
Author(s): David F. Larcker; Brian Tayan
Case No: CG10
Publication Year: 2007
Keywords: Executive Compensation, Board of Directors, insider trading, Corporate Governance, stock options
Paper Copy Available: You may purchase this case from Harvard Business Publishing
Electronic Copy Available: GSB Faculty, Students and Staff only may view PDF document, authorization required.
To view and print the PDF, you'll need Adobe's free Acrobat Reader, downloadable from Adobe's site. Get Acrobat 
If you encounter problems ordering or downloading this document, contact cases_requests@gsb.stanford.edu